Articel courtesy of Nelsy Rodriguez | December 3, 2012 | The Press Enterprise
The results of an independent analysis of contaminated water going to more than 100 homes in Wildomar and Menifee shows the problem may be getting worse.
On Nov. 26, a group of Mt. San Jacinto College water quality students and their water technology instructor launched a project to analyze the nitrate levels in County Water Company of Riverside’s water. The small, private water company has failed to meet state deadlines for efforts to provide safe drinking water to its customers.
Lead by Michael Creighton, a former water quality official who now teaches at Mt. San Jacinto, the group took samples from a tank and sent the water for testing at a Riverside lab.
The results, Creighton said Monday, show the water now contains 97 milligrams per liter, an increase of 11 milligrams per liter since the last official reading recorded in June by the Riverside County Department of Environmental Health. The California Water Code limits the level of nitrates to 45 milligrams per liter.
Although all potable water contains nitrates, ingestion of too many can cause health effects as the nitrates complicate the blood’s ability to carry oxygen.
“To me, that’s significantly higher,” said Creighton, a former water quality director with Eastern Municipal Water District.
In response to the reading, Riverside County spokesman Raymond Smith said retesting nitrate levels is valuable for continued monitoring of the situation.
“Nitrate levels can vary, depending on the season, because of rainfall and groundwater usage,” Smith said in an emailed statement. “The county continues to recommend that residents not use the water supplied by County Water Company for drinking or cooking. The County Water Company is bound by requirements to keep residents informed about restrictions on how they should use the water.”
High nitrates in the water have been an issue since at least 2003 and various attempts by the county and the California Department of Public Health to assist the water district owner to correct the issue have been unsuccessful.
Now, the company’s owner, Rafael Spears, is hoping to secure a state grant to research the best way to clean the water. Options include purchasing water from neighboring water districts to dilute the nitrate level and shutting down the district all together, said Spears’ attorney, Wayne Rosenbaum of the Stoel Rives law firm in San Diego.
State officials and water company representatives are scheduled to meet on Jan. 10 to discuss the long-range options, Rosenbaum said.
“We would like to move this project forward as quickly as possible,” Rosenbaum said. “But are limited in our options without support from the State and coordination with the surrounding water districts.”
While the water company addresses the problem through legal channels, Creighton’s group is working to organize the water district customers, many of whom are native Spanish speakers. In addition to collecting more water samples Monday, Creighton and the students, as well as interpreters and a medical student, handed out fliers alerting residents to the most recent nitrate reading.
While it has been common knowledge among customers that they should not drink their water – boiling is not an option as that actually raises the nitrate level – the group is organizing a safe drinking water campaign to raise awareness about the condition of the water outside of the neighborhood.
“What I’m trying to establish is the perimeter (of the tainted water), what it looks like geographically,” Creighton said. “My goal is to do the survey, find out as much information as we can about each resident so then we can document the results.”
Nitrate is a colorless, odorless, and tasteless compound that is present in some groundwater in Colorado.
Nitrate can be expressed as either NO3 (nitrate) or NO3-N (nitrate-nitrogen). Nitrate levels above the EPA Maximum Contaminant Level of 10mg/l NO3- N or 45 mg/l NO3 may cause methemoglobinemia in infants.
Proper management of fertilizers, manures, and other nitrogen sources can minimize contamination of drinking water supplies.
[toggle title=” Nitrate (NO3) is a naturally occurring form of nitrogen found in soil.” height=”auto”]
Nitrate (NO3) is a naturally occurring form of nitrogen found in soil. Nitrogen is essential to all life. Most crop plants require large quantities to sustain high yields.
The formation of nitrates is an integral part of the nitrogen cycle in our environment. In moderate amounts, nitrate is a harmless constituent of food and water. Plants use nitrates from the soil to satisfy nutria.nt requirements and may accumulate nitrate in their leaves and stems. Due to its high mobility, nitrate also can leach into groundwater. If people or animals drink water high in nitrate, it may cause methemoglobinemia, an illness found especially in infants.
Nitrates form when microorganisms break down fertilizers, decaying plants, manures or other organic residues. Usually plants take up these nitrates, but sometimes rain or irrigation water can leach them into groundwater. Although nitrate occurs naturally in some groundwater, in most cases higher levels are thought to result from human activities. Common sources of nitrate include:
fertilizers and manure,
municipal wastewater and sludge,
septic systems, and
N-fixation from atmosphere by legumes, bacteria and lightning.
Health Effect of Nitrates
High nitrate levels in water can cause methemoglobinemia or blue baby syndrome, a condition found especially in infants under six months. The stomach acid of an infant is not as strong as in older children and adults. This causes an increase in bacteria that can readily convert nitrate to nitrite (NO2). Do not let infants drink water that exceeds 10 mg/l NO3-N. This includes formula preparation.
Nitrite is absorbed in the blood, and hemoglobin (the oxygen-carrying component of blood) is converted to methemoglobin. Methemoglobin does not carry oxygen efficiently. This results in a reduced oxygen supply to vital tissues such as the brain. Methemoglobin in infant blood cannot change back to hemoglobin, which normally occurs in adults. Severe methemoglobinemia can result in brain damage and death.
Pregnant women, adults with reduced stomach acidity, and people deficient in the enzyme that changes methemoglobin back to normal hemoglobin are all susceptible to nitrite-induced methemoglobinemia. The most obvious symptom of methemoglobinemia is a bluish color of the skin, particularly around the eyes and mouth. Other symptoms include headache, dizziness, weakness or difficulty in breathing. Take babies with the above symptoms to the hospital emergency room immediately. If recognized in time, methemoglobinemia is treated easily with an injection of methylene blue.
Healthy adults can consume fairly large amounts of nitrate with few known health effects. In fact, most of the nitrate we consume is from our diets, particularly from raw or cooked vegetables. This nitrate is readily absorbed and excreted in the urine. However, prolonged intake of high levels of nitrate are linked to gastric problems due to the formations of nitrosamines. N-nitrosamine compounds have been shown to cause cancer in test animals. Studies of people exposed to high levels of nitrate or nitrite have not provided convincing evidence of an increased risk of cancer.
Although there is no enforceable drinking water standard for livestock, do not allow animals to drink water with more than 100 mg/l NO3-N. This is especially true of young animals. They are affected by nitrates the same way as human babies. Older animals may tolerate higher levels.
Ruminant animals (cattle, sheep) are susceptible to nitrate poisoning because bacteria present in the rumen convert nitrate to nitrite. Nonruminant animals (swine, chickens) rapidly eliminate nitrate in their urine. Horses are monogastric, but their large cecum acts much like a rumen. This makes them more susceptible to nitrate poisoning than other monogastric animals.
It is difficult to determine the toxicity of nitrate in animals because it depends on the rate at which the substance is consumed. A few hundred milligrams of nitrate may cause poisoning if consumed in a few hours. But spread over a whole day, 1,000 mg nitrate may cause no signs of toxicity.
Common symptoms include abdominal pain, diarrhea, muscular weakness or poor coordination. Affected animals will have blood that is a chocolate-brown color. If the problem is diagnosed in time, they can fully recover with a treatment of methylene blue. Pregnant animals may abort within a few days.
Nitrate also exists in animal feeds and fodder. Drought-stressed forage plants commonly have high nitrate levels. These feeds can have an additive effect when consumed with high nitrate drinking water.
The drinking water standard
Reports of methemoglobinemia are extremely rare. Clinical infant methemoglobinemia was first recognized in 1945. About 2,000 cases were reported in North America and Europe by 1971. Fatality rates were reported to be approximately 7 to 8 percent. From 1960 to 1972, however, only one death from blue baby syndrome was documented.
Methemoglobinemia has not been reported where water contains less than 10 mg/l of NO3-N. This level has been adopted by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency as the standard in the Primary Drinking Water Regulations, chiefly to protect young infants.
Nitrate values are commonly reported as either nitrate (NO3) or as nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N). The maximum contaminant level (MCL) in drinking water as nitrate (NO3) is 45 mg/l, whereas the MCL as NO3-N is 10 mg/l.
The MCL is the highest level of NO3 or NO3-N that is allowable in public drinking water supplies by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). These figures also may be reported in ppm (parts per million), which is equivalent to mg/l. Be sure you know which value is reported for your water sample.
Protecting your drinking water
The 1990 EPA National Survey of Drinking Water Wells found that approximately 57 percent of the private wells tested contained detectable levels of nitrates. However, only 2.4 percent exceeded the EPA maximum contaminant level. In Colorado, nitrate contamination above the MCL occurs mainly in rural areas overlying vulnerable aquifers.
Protecting your drinking water supply from contamination is important for health and to protect property values and minimize potential liability. High nitrate levels often are associated with poorly constructed or improperly located wells. Locate new wells uphill and at least 100 feet away from feedlots, septic systems, barnyards and chemical storage facilities. Properly seal or cap abandoned wells.
Manage nonpoint sources of water pollution (fields, lawns) to limit the loss of excess water and plant nutrients. Match fertilizer and irrigation applications to precise crop uptake needs in order to minimize groundwater contamination.
Best management practices for fertilizer use
Careful fertilizer management can reduce nitrate leaching to groundwater. Consider the following practices in planning your fertilizer program:
Use soil and water analysis to determine exact nitrogen needs of crop (see fact sheet 0.500, Soil Sampling).
Set a realistic yield goal for each field. Take the five-year average production of your field and add 5 percent to get an attainable yield goal.
Credit all sources of nitrogen available to the crop, including manures, water, organic matter, legumes and residual subsoil nitrate.
Water quality analysis
Nitrate is a tasteless, colorless and odorless compound that you cannot detect unless your water is chemically analyzed. If you drink water from a private well, get a qualified laboratory to test it yearly. The local health department or Colorado State University Extension county office usually can supply the name of an approved testing laboratory in your area.
Sample water for nitrate testing at the well site or at a tap inside the house. Place samples in clean, 4- to 16-ounce plastic containers. Send the sample to a laboratory immediately. Refrigerating it will help keep it intact until it reaches a laboratory. Do not freeze it.
Laboratory results will be compared to the MCL, and recommendations for treatment should be considered if nitrate levels exceed 10 mg/l NO3-N. Be aware that nitrate levels in groundwater may vary seasonally. If your water tests high or borderline high, retest your water every three to six months.
Purification of contaminated water
While it may be technically possible to treat contaminated groundwater, it can be difficult, expensive and not totally effective. For this reason, prevention is the best way to ensure clean water. Water treatments include distillation, reverse osmosis, ion exchange or blending.
Distillation boils the water, catches the resulting steam, and condenses the steam on a cold surface (a condenser). Nitrates and other minerals remain behind in the boiling tank.
Reverse osmosis forces water under pressure through a membrane that filters out minerals and nitrate. One-half to two-thirds of the water remains behind the membrane as rejected water. Higher-yield systems use water pressures of 150 psi.
Ion-exchange takes another substance, such as chloride, and trades places with nitrate. An ion exchange unit is filled with special resin beads that are charged with chloride. As water passes over the beads, the resin takes up nitrate in exchange for chloride. As more water passes over the resin, all the chloride is exchanged for nitrate. The resin is recharged by backwashing with sodium chloride solution. The backwash solution, which is high in nitrate, must be properly disposed of.
Blending is another method to reduce nitrates in drinking water. Mix contaminated water with clean water from another source to lower overall nitrate concentration. Blended water is not safe for infants but is acceptable for livestock and healthy adults.
Charcoal filters and water softeners do not adequately remove nitrates from water. Boiling nitrate-contaminated water does not make it safe to drink and actually increases the concentration of nitrates. Drilling a new well to deeper water with less nitrate may be a feasible remedy in certain areas. In many cases, the most effective alternative is to use bottled water for drinking and cooking.
Blue baby syndrome: A disease that affects the oxygen carrying capacity of infant’s blood, usually resulting from the consumption of high levels of NO3. Also known as methemoglobinemia.
Contaminant: Any physical, chemical, biological or radiological substance that degrades water quality.
Groundwater: Water that saturates subsurface formations or aquifers.
Leaching: The downward movement of dissolved or suspended minerals, fertilizers, agricultural chemicals or other substances through the soil.
Maximum contaminant level (MCL): The highest amount of a specific contaminant allowed by the EPA in public drinking water supplies. These are health-based standards that by law must be set as close to the “no-risk” level as feasible.
Nitrate (NO3): An important plant nutrient that is soluble in water and may cause health problems if consumed in large amounts.
Nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N): Relates to the actual nitrogen in nitrate. Multiply NO3-N values by 4.4 to convert to nitrate.
Nonpoint source pollution: Water contamination from diffuse sources such as agricultural fields, urban runoff or large construction sites.
Parts per million (ppm): A unit of proportion used to describe the concentration of a chemical in water. Equivalent to mg/l.
Additional information on water quality can be obtained from the following fact sheets, published by Colorado State University Extension:
J. R. Self. 1998. Domestic Water Quality Criteria. 0.513.
Kendall, P. 1992. Drinking Water Quality. 9.307.
Self, J. R., and P. N. Soltanpour. 1997. Soil Sampling. 0.500.
Soltanpour, P. N., I. Broner, and R. H. Follett. 1999. Nitrogen and Irrigation Management. 0.514.
Soltanpour, P. N. and W. L. Raley. 1993. Livestock Drinking Water Quality. 4.908.
Stanton, T. L. 1992. Nitrate Poisoning. 1.610.
1J.R. Self, Colorado State University Soils Testing Laboratory manager; and R.M. Waskom, Colorado State Extension water quality specialist; soil and crop sciences. 7/95. Reviewed 10/08.